The honest answer to what a new roof costs is that it depends on things a website cannot see: the size and shape of the slopes, what is coming off, what is going back on, how the scaffold has to be built and what the timbers look like once the covering is gone. What can be explained is where the money goes, which is what lets you read three quotes and understand why they differ.
The covering is the cheapest part
Owners price a roof by looking up the cost of tiles, and the tiles are rarely the largest line. Stripping the old covering and getting it off site is labour and skips. The scaffold is priced by the week and has to enclose the whole working edge. Battens and breathable underlay go on every square metre. Ridges, verges, valleys, flashings and any leadwork are detail work by the metre. Put together, the parts that are not the covering routinely come to more than the covering itself, which is why a quote that only itemises tiles has not been broken down.
What makes one roof dearer than the next
Access is the first multiplier: a detached house with clear ground on all four sides is cheaper to scaffold than a terrace with a shared alley. Complexity is the second: every valley, dormer, chimney and change of pitch is a detail somebody has to form by hand. Height is the third, because a third storey is another lift of scaffold. And the covering is the fourth, with natural slate at one end of the range and a concrete interlocking tile at the other, on the same roof, for a very different number.
How to make three quotes comparable
Write the specification yourself, in one paragraph, and give the same paragraph to all three contractors. Name the covering you want quoted, say whether the underlay is to be a breathable membrane, ask for dry ridge and dry verge to be priced rather than assumed, and ask each of them to state a provisional sum for replacing rotten timber rather than leaving it out. Then ask what is excluded. The exclusions are the part of a roofing quote that predicts the final invoice.
Questions people ask about how much does a new roof cost
Is it cheaper to repair or replace a roof?
A repair is cheaper today and the comparison only becomes clear when you know why the roof is failing. Slipped tiles on a sound roof are a repair. Tiles slipping every winter because the nails or battens have perished are a symptom, and repairing them repeatedly costs more over a decade than recovering the slope once.
Should the loft insulation be upgraded during a re-roof?
It is the cheapest moment to do it, and where a roof is being recovered the energy efficiency requirements of the Building Regulations can be triggered for that element. Ask the contractor to price it as an option before the scaffold goes up.
Does a new roof add value to a house?
A roof at the end of its life is a deduction from an offer rather than an addition to it. Buyers and their surveyors price a roof that needs doing; they rarely pay a premium for one that has just been done.